Home & Garden

Vocational Horticulture and the Greenhouse Workforce Gap

An industry adviser argues that high-school programs and commercial growers should collaborate earlier and year-round to build practical growing careers.

Amelie ToussaintOctober 26, 20265 min read6 views

Generic students and a grower inspect plants, sticky cards and roots in a school greenhouse, with commercial production areas visible beyond.

In greenhouse horticulture, the workforce conversation usually starts with the immediate shortage: growers are hard to find, especially growers with practical production experience. Jeff Neese, a Biological Solutions Advisor for BioWorks with more than 35 years in commercial horticulture and integrated pest management, argues in an industry essay that this conversation begins too late. His case is not that schools should supply employers with ready-made labor. It is that young people need earlier, broader exposure to horticulture before they are asked to choose a career, and that commercial growers have a practical role in providing it.

Neese grounds the argument in his own experience at Warren Central High School in Indianapolis. A winter visit to the school greenhouse, warm and green against a cold Indiana landscape, led him into vocational horticulture. Two teachers, Phil Pitts and Pam Greene, shaped that experience. Pitts brought real-world work as a grower and landscape designer and set high expectations; Greene taught floriculture. Neese says the program gave him knowledge, experience and confidence, and he entered horticulture directly after high school rather than going to college. He is careful to say that the industry still needs university-trained horticulturists, plant scientists, breeders, researchers and growers. His point is that a four-year degree should not be the only respected route into the profession, nor the first place a young person encounters it.

Why summer internships are not enough

The article identifies a gap between the industry's recruiting tactics and the age at which career discovery happens. Neese notes that a 15- or 16-year-old is unlikely to wake up and decide that greenhouse production sounds fascinating. Someone has to show them. That is why he sees high-school vocational horticulture as important to the future workforce, but he does not treat a greenhouse behind a school as sufficient by itself. A greenhouse is a living laboratory, and running one requires crop scheduling, irrigation, fertility, pH and EC management, pest and disease diagnosis, environmental control and time. Agriculture teachers may cover broad subjects; expecting each of them to be an accomplished greenhouse grower and IPM practitioner is unrealistic.

His proposed remedy is partnership rather than delegation. Commercial greenhouse operations could effectively adopt their local school greenhouses, not to take over the curriculum or displace the teacher, but to serve as a technical resource. Growers could help develop an achievable crop plan and realistic standards for irrigation, fertility, pH, EC, temperature and crop timing. They could walk the greenhouse with students, teach scouting, show how sticky cards and root inspections are used, explain how nutritional problems are diagnosed, and demonstrate how growers think through decisions. They could also help teachers use equipment already in the greenhouse and give them a knowledgeable contact when problems arise. The underlying observation is that commercial horticulture holds a large body of practical growing knowledge, but most of it stays inside commercial greenhouse walls.

Neese does not dismiss summer internships. He says they are important but insufficient on their own. For many high-school students, summer is the only extended period for full-time work, and the experience can be narrow. Much of spring's diversity and activity may be over; the weather is hot and humid; and inexperienced seasonal employees may be assigned tasks such as sticking poinsettias, spacing crops, moving plants or cleaning houses. Neese says there is nothing wrong with those jobs—they are part of commercial horticulture and teach the physical work of crop production—but if that is a teenager's only exposure, the industry should not be surprised if greenhouse horticulture does not look exciting as a career. Their exposure is to greenhouse labor rather than management.

Seeing the full production cycle

To understand growing, students need to see how production changes across the year. Neese lists fall crops and shortening days; winter's lower light and humidity challenges; spring propagation and the demanding peak season; and summer's heat, irrigation demands and preparation for the next cycle. Each stage brings different crops, problems and decisions. An eight-week summer internship gives one snapshot; learning horticulture, in his view, requires the full production year.

That leads to his proposal that school and commercial greenhouses complement each other. If a participating grower understands what students are learning, the summer internship becomes part of a continuous education rather than a disconnected job. If students have studied pH and EC, they can see commercial monitoring. If they have learned scouting and IPM, they can join a crop walk with the person responsible. If they have studied irrigation and fertility, they can see injectors, water systems and fertilizer programs. Even repetitive work becomes more meaningful when students understand the decisions behind it. Sticking a poinsettia cutting, for example, can be connected to the production schedule, rooting, transplant timing, crop monitoring and the finished-crop date.

The partnership could continue through the school year: growers visiting classrooms, assisting with crop planning, helping students troubleshoot the school greenhouse, and inviting classes into commercial operations at different points in the production cycle. By the time students arrive for summer employment, they are no longer only inexperienced seasonal labor; they are beginning to understand why the work matters. Neese also sees a recruiting advantage. A student might first meet a company as a sophomore in horticulture classes, visit or work with the operation as a junior, continue in the school greenhouse as a senior, and graduate with a visible career path.

He extends the argument to career development after graduation. For students who attend college, that may be the right next step. But for those who cannot attend, do not want to attend, or know they want to start working, there should be another respected path. An 18-year-old with several years of vocational horticulture, meaningful commercial exposure and mentorship from experienced growers should not be treated simply as unskilled labor. Neese describes that person as a young horticulturist at the beginning of a career and urges employers to give responsibility, continue teaching and show where the career can lead. He also notes that some of the most rewarding growers he has worked with were people he helped develop; they learned crops and operations from the ground up because someone invested time in teaching them.

A shared responsibility, not a school-only task

The article's conclusion is organizational as much as educational. Schools cannot be expected to solve the industry's workforce challenges alone, and commercial growers cannot solve vocational education alone. Neese argues that the opportunity lies between those worlds. Instead of relying only on career fairs, job postings and complaints that applicants lack practical experience, growers can become involved earlier: find a local agricultural education or horticulture program, meet the teacher, walk through the school greenhouse, ask what is needed and offer knowledge rather than only old equipment or leftover plants. He also urges growers to invite students into their operations in February as well as June, letting them scout, test EC, examine roots, see good and problem crops, make mistakes, ask questions and understand production decisions. The summer job, in that model, should not be only the work nobody else wants; it should give a student a reason to want the grower's job someday.

The essay's closing image is a teenager walking into a greenhouse for the first time. Neese says Phil Pitts and Pam Greene opened that door for him, and that horticulture was not a fallback if college failed but the opportunity itself. More than four decades later, he says, he still carries their lessons into greenhouses. His practical implication is conditional rather than proven: if the industry is serious about where the next generation will come from, it should not assume another party will supply that pipeline. The next generation may already be seated in high-school classrooms, but it needs both school programs and commercial partners to develop.