Beauty

CTPA panel urges context, consistency and listening to counter beauty misinformation

Industry, government and journalism experts at CTPA’s first scientific conference outlined practical ways to improve public understanding of beauty science.

Dalia MansourOctober 27, 20265 min read3 views

Unbranded cosmetic bottles and laboratory glassware sit on a bench as abstract information streams converge through a prism into a single beam beside a stylized ear symbol.

Government and industry representatives used the Cosmetic, Toiletry and Perfumery Association’s inaugural scientific conference to examine how scientific evidence, regulatory decision-making and public understanding can converge at a time of information overload and widespread misinformation in beauty. The members-only event was held at Central Hall Westminster in London.

In opening remarks, Caroline Rainsford, director of science at CTPA, said strong science communication is essential. She said people in different roles spend their days trying to turn complicated scientific information into material that audiences can manage and understand. Later, during a panel on building trust through science communication, she said putting science into context for consumers is always helpful.

Rainsford illustrated the point with a discussion she recalled having with salon professionals about an ingredient banned in nail polish. She said the context was that a person would have to wear two kilograms of nail polish to approach the level that causes harm. She added that placing such details in context resonates with people.

Marc Pissavini, sun research lab director at Coty, agreed that context matters. He said an Olympic swimming pool analogy can help communicate the relevance of a liquid: at two litres a day, one pool would take an individual around 4,500 years to drink. If that is explained, he said, people understand that a drop in a swimming pool is not a lot. To fight misinformation, he argued, the first step is to explain and give consumers the keys to measure or understand the issue.

Pissavini also linked credibility to consistency. He said the industry needs to speak with one voice, although that does not always happen. If dermatologists, doctors, large companies and others stopped saying “I” and started saying “we,” as pharmacy and large groups do, the collective message could be stronger, he suggested.

Wendy Middleton, chief scientific officer and director for science at the UK government’s Office for Product Safety and Standards, said the idea of one voice is interesting but also raised a challenge: scientists are not very good at doing that. She noted that the crux of credible science is that it has been critiqued and peer-reviewed. She said she was not suggesting that should stop, but that scientists should be more cognisant of their profession and how they communicate with one another.

Pissavini, who is also editor of the peer-reviewed International Journal of Cosmetic Science, said it is crucial for the scientific community to keep the peer review process. The challenge today, he said, is finding reviewers and communicating better with audiences, including readers inside and outside the industry.

Rainsford said the industry needs to work collectively to demystify what peer review means. Most people do not understand how the process works, she said, including some industry members. Looking ahead, she said transparency and explaining exactly what the process involves will be important.

Claire Coleman, a journalist, editor and specialist consultant on the science behind beauty, said it is also important to establish where misinformed conversations are happening. She said the best approach is to begin where the misinformation is when trying to correct it, meet people where they are and make them understand. For her, that means finding out where the misinformation is and making sure to stand on the same platform.

Middleton agreed that meeting people where they are is critical. She said government used to talk a lot about hard-to-reach consumers, but they are not hard to reach; they are hard for communicators to hear. When it comes to reaching consumers, she said, taking more responsibility for listening is key.

Coleman added that the beauty industry must understand it will not be able to convert or reach everyone. She said communicators should not focus on hard-liners but on “floating voters” — consumers who are uncertain and looking to better understand the subject.

Roger Pullin, head of chemicals policy and health at the UK’s Chemical Industries Association, said technical terms and acronyms are best avoided where possible when communicating with consumers. He said messages should be framed from a consumer perspective and be precise and clear without losing the science. That becomes tricky with complex subjects such as risk-based exposure, he said, but it should remain the goal.

Pullin also said companies can provide a more balanced scientific perspective in communications. Science is not necessarily black and white, he said, and that is a problem the sector does have. Transparency is key, but so is acknowledging where uncertainties lie. He said organisations should consider being upfront and direct about what is actually unknown, rather than avoiding awkward questions.

Emma Meredith, director-general of CTPA, closed the conference by saying that how the industry communicates science, and whether it communicates it well, is critical.